Invest or Pay Down the Mortgage? When Higher Interest Rates Change the Equation
I recently read a very interesting article in the Australian Financial Review by Michaela Pollock and investment adviser Rob Pizzichetta about a question that comes up regularly in financial planning:
If you have spare cash, should you invest it or put it against the home loan?
It sounds straightforward, but the answer becomes considerably more interesting when mortgage rates are around 6 per cent or higher.
The article describes the decision using a useful “three-zone” framework. What caught my attention was not simply the conclusion, but the reminder that we should compare an investment return with the after-tax cost of debt, rather than comparing two headline percentages.
A Mortgage Saving Is Not the Same as an Investment Return
Imagine you have $100,000 available and a home loan charging 6.25 per cent.
If that $100,000 sits in an effective mortgage offset account, it could reduce the interest charged on the loan by approximately $6,250 over a year, assuming the loan balance, offset amount and rate remained unchanged.
There is an important distinction here. You have not actually earned $6,250 of investment income. You have avoided paying $6,250 of interest.
For an owner-occupied home where the interest is a private expense, that saving generally does not create taxable investment income. By contrast, dividends and other investment income can have income-tax consequences, while selling investments at a gain can have CGT consequences.
That makes the comparison more complicated than saying, “My mortgage costs 6.25 per cent and I think shares might return more than that.”
The purpose for which borrowed money is used is important to tax deductibility. The Australian Taxation Office confirms, for example, that interest on money borrowed to acquire income-producing investments can generally be deductible, whereas deductibility depends on the income-producing use of the borrowed funds.
The Investment Hurdle Can Be Higher Than It Looks
This is the point made particularly well in the Australian Financial Review discussion.
If avoiding 6.25 per cent mortgage interest produces an after-tax household saving of 6.25 per cent, a taxable investment may need to produce a higher pre-tax return to leave the investor with an equivalent amount after tax.
Using a simplified assumption of a 30 per cent effective tax rate, an 8.93 per cent taxable return would leave approximately 6.25 per cent after tax:
8.93% × (1 − 30%) ≈ 6.25%
At a mortgage rate of 6.50 per cent, the equivalent simplified hurdle becomes approximately 9.29 per cent.
That is quite a different proposition.
However, I would not treat 8.93 per cent or 9.29 per cent as a universal break-even point. Real investment taxation is more complicated. Australian shares may pay franked dividends, some return may arrive as capital growth rather than income, CGT can be deferred until sale, eligible individuals may receive the CGT discount, and everybody’s marginal tax rate is different.
The useful lesson is not the precise percentage.
The lesson is that the comparison should be made after tax and after considering risk.
The Other Difference Is Certainty
This is where paying down, or offsetting, a mortgage becomes particularly interesting.
If your home loan rate is 6.25 per cent and $100,000 remains in an offset account for a full year, the interest saving is relatively straightforward to calculate. If the variable mortgage rate changes, so does the benefit.
The sharemarket is very different.
Shares may produce a much higher return over time, but there is no certainty about what they will return next year. A good year can produce substantial gains. A poor year can leave the portfolio worth less than where it started.
That does not make shares inappropriate. Growth assets play an important role in long-term wealth creation precisely because investors accept uncertainty and volatility in pursuit of higher long-term returns.
But it does mean that 6.25 per cent of interest avoided and an assumed 6.25 per cent investment return are not equivalent propositions.
One is an interest saving determined by the mortgage balance and rate. The other involves investment risk.
Your Time Horizon Changes the Conversation
This is where I think personal circumstances become much more important than the mathematics.
Consider someone in their late fifties who wants to retire in five years and would strongly prefer to enter retirement without a mortgage.
For that person, reducing non-deductible home debt may provide value beyond the interest saved. A smaller mortgage can mean lower required household cash flow in retirement and less exposure to future interest-rate movements.
Now consider someone much younger with a secure income, a long investment horizon and a manageable mortgage. That person may place greater value on building investments over several decades and may be more comfortable accepting market volatility.
The same interest rate applies to both people.
The appropriate decision can still be completely different.
An Offset Account and Paying Off the Loan Are Not Quite the Same Thing
This distinction is also worth making.
Putting surplus cash into a genuine offset account can reduce the amount of home-loan interest calculated while generally preserving access to the cash, subject to the lender and account terms.
Making additional repayments directly onto a loan can also reduce interest, but access to that money later depends on the loan's redraw arrangements. The tax consequences can become more complicated if money is subsequently redrawn for another purpose because interest deductibility is determined by how borrowed funds are used. The Australian Taxation Office specifically distinguishes between private and income-producing uses of borrowed money.
That distinction can become particularly important for people who may later convert their current home into an investment property or who are thinking about borrowing to invest.
It is one of those areas where a seemingly minor banking decision today can have consequences later.
It Does Not Have to Be All or Nothing
Another thing I like about this discussion is that it does not necessarily require an investor to choose one side permanently.
For some households, an appropriate strategy may involve retaining an emergency reserve in an offset account while continuing regular long-term investing. Others may place greater emphasis on reducing their mortgage as retirement approaches.
The allocation can also change over time.
What matters is understanding why each dollar is being directed somewhere.
Money needed for a renovation in two years has a very different job from money intended to remain invested for twenty years. An emergency reserve has a different purpose again.
That is why I would be wary of making this decision from a simple comparison between the mortgage rate and the long-term historical return from shares.
The Question Is Bigger Than “Which Will Make More?”
When clients ask whether they should invest or pay down their mortgage, it is tempting to answer with a spreadsheet.
The spreadsheet matters, but it does not capture everything.
I also want to know when they hope to retire, how secure their income is, how much debt they are comfortable carrying, whether they have sufficient cash reserves, how they react when investment markets fall and what else they want their money to achieve.
For some people, investing will remain important. For others, the combination of higher mortgage rates, tax considerations and the desire to enter retirement with less debt will make reducing the home loan increasingly attractive.
And for many families, the answer will be somewhere between the two.
The Australian Financial Review article was a useful reminder that when interest rates are higher, doing nothing more sophisticated than reducing non-deductible home-loan interest can become a surprisingly high hurdle for an alternative investment strategy to beat after tax and risk are considered.
The mathematics is useful.
But the better question is not simply, “Which option could produce the highest return?”
It is “Which option puts me in the stronger position to achieve what I am actually trying to achieve?”
General information only
This article contains general information and does not take into account any person's objectives, financial situation or needs. It does not constitute personal financial, taxation or credit advice. Investment returns are uncertain and past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Mortgage rates, taxation outcomes and the operation of offset and redraw facilities vary. Before investing, changing loan arrangements or acting on taxation considerations, seek appropriate professional advice.
