Giving Back: What Do You Want Your Legacy to Look Like?
Luisa Capezio, Aged Care Adviser
Last week I attended an educational function hosted by a local charity on giving and philanthropy. I went expecting much of the conversation to be about charitable donations. Instead, I came away thinking about something much broader: what do we actually want our wealth to achieve, both during our lifetime and after we are gone?
It is an interesting question, particularly for people who have spent much of their lives building a business, supporting a family, paying off debt and accumulating enough to enjoy a comfortable retirement.
We spend decades asking,“Will I have enough?” Eventually, some people are fortunate enough to arrive at a different question:
“If I do have enough, what would I like to do with it?”
That can open a very different conversation about family, community, philanthropy and legacy.
Giving Does Not Have to Wait Until You Die
One of the ideas discussed at the function was giving during your lifetime rather than leaving all charitable intentions to your will.
I think there is something particularly appealing about being able to see the impact of your generosity.
For one family, that might mean supporting a local organisation that helped somebody they love. For another, it might be medical research, education, disadvantaged children, the arts, environmental causes or community services.
The amount does not necessarily need to be enormous. Philanthropy is sometimes presented as something undertaken by people whose names eventually appear on buildings, but giving can be much simpler than that.
You might make donations directly to organisations you care about. You might decide to give a particular amount every year. For people who want a more structured approach and have sufficient resources, philanthropic structures can also allow money to be set aside for charitable purposes during their lifetime, with grants subsequently made to eligible organisations.
This introduces an element I particularly like: giving becomes part of the family's story rather than simply an instruction contained in a will.
Parents may be able to involve adult children in conversations about which causes matter to the family and why. In some circumstances, children and grandchildren can participate in decisions about future giving.
The legacy then becomes more than the money itself. It can also pass on values.
A Legacy in Your Will
For other people, giving during retirement may not feel appropriate. They may want to retain their capital because they are uncertain about future health costs, aged care, longevity or what assistance their family may eventually require.
That does not mean philanthropy needs to disappear from the estate plan.
A charitable bequest can be included in a will, allowing a person to support an organisation or cause after death. Depending on the individual's wishes and legal advice, a bequest might involve a particular sum, a specific asset or a proportion of an estate.
The important issue is making the intention clear and ensuring the estate-planning documents are properly drafted.
I particularly like the conversation this can create around what is enough.
Many parents understandably want to leave something meaningful to their children. But if you have built substantial wealth, there may come a point where leaving every remaining dollar to the next generation is not necessarily your only objective.
Perhaps the family receives the majority of the estate while a portion supports a cause that was important throughout your life.
That is an intensely personal decision. There is no correct percentage and no obligation to leave money to charity. What matters is making the decision deliberately rather than allowing your estate plan to become simply,“Whatever is left goes to the children.”
Creating a More Structured Giving Plan
For people who want philanthropy to become a significant part of their wealth planning, Australia also has formal philanthropic structures, including Private Ancillary Funds and Public Ancillary Funds.
These are more sophisticated than simply making a donation. They operate within specific regulatory and tax rules and are designed to provide a structure through which funds can ultimately be distributed to eligible charitable organisations.
They will not suit everybody. Establishment, administration, governance and distribution requirements need to be considered, so professional tax and legal advice is important before proceeding.
However, for the right family, structured giving can change philanthropy from a series of individual donations into something much more deliberate and potentially intergenerational.
That may allow a family to ask questions such as: What issues do we genuinely care about? Do we want our children involved? Should we support a small number of organisations over many years rather than making occasional donations to many different causes?
Those are not really tax questions. They are family questions.
And Then There Is the Tax Question
Tax should not be the reason somebody gives, but naturally it forms part of the planning conversation.
For a donation to qualify for a tax deduction, the recipient generally needs to have Deductible Gift Recipient (DGR) status, and the payment must satisfy the requirements for a deductible gift. Importantly, being a registered charity does not automatically mean an organisation has DGR status. The Australian Taxation Office advises donors to check DGR status before assuming a donation is deductible.
A deductible gift must generally be voluntary and made without receiving a material benefit in return. This is why buying something at a fundraiser is not necessarily treated in the same way as making a straightforward donation. Special rules can also apply to gifts of property and shares.
There is also workplace giving, where employees donate through their employer's payroll system. The Australian Taxation Office recognises eligible workplace-giving donations to DGRs as deductible donations.
These details matter because the statement that donations to "most registered charities" are tax deductible is too broad. Before relying on a deduction, the DGR status of the particular recipient should be checked.
Giving While Living or Leaving a Legacy?
For me, this was the most interesting part of last week's discussion.
There is no reason it necessarily needs to be one or the other.
Someone might support causes modestly throughout retirement while retaining sufficient capital for their own security. Later, their will might contain a larger charitable bequest. Another family may establish a structured giving arrangement and involve the next generation. Someone else may simply nominate two or three organisations that have been important to them and support those organisations directly during their lifetime.
The right approach depends on how much you have, how much you may need, your family circumstances and what you want the money to accomplish.
For retirees, I think the order of those considerations is important. Generosity should not come at the expense of your own financial security. Before making significant gifts, it is sensible to understand the effect on retirement cash flow, future care needs, tax and the estate you intend to leave to your family.
Once those issues have been considered, however, giving can become a very rewarding part of wealth planning.
What Does Your Family Want to Be Remembered For?
We often talk about legacy as though it simply means inheritance.
I think it can mean much more than that.
Legacy can be the opportunities you create for your children and grandchildren. It can be the values you pass on. It can be helping your community while you are here to see the difference. And it can be ensuring that causes important to you continue to receive support long after you are gone.
Perhaps the most valuable outcome from last week's function was not learning another way to structure a donation. It was being reminded to ask a better question.
Not simply, “How much will I leave behind?” but, “What do I want the wealth I have created to achieve?”
For families fortunate enough to have choices around their wealth, that can be a very meaningful conversation to start.
General information only
This article is provided for educational and general information purposes and does not take into account any person's objectives, financial situation or needs. It does not constitute personal financial, taxation or legal advice. Tax deductibility depends on the recipient, type of gift and individual circumstances. Estate planning and structured philanthropy can involve specific legal and taxation requirements, so appropriate professional advice should be obtained before making significant gifts or changing estate-planning arrangements.
