Education Bonds and Investment Bonds: What Is the Difference?
Craig Phillips, Snr financial adviser
I have been having more conversations lately with parents and grandparents about helping the next generation.
For some, the priority is school fees or university. Others want to help grandchildren with education but also want flexibility if circumstances change. And increasingly, I meet grandparents who would like to put money aside now, retain some control over how it is invested, and ultimately know that it will benefit their family.
This is where Education Bonds and Investment Bonds can enter the conversation.
At first glance they can look very similar. Both are long-term investment structures in which tax on investment earnings is generally dealt with within the bond rather than requiring the investor to include those ongoing earnings personally each year. However, an Education Bond has an additional feature designed specifically around funding education.
That difference can be important.
First, What Is an Investment Bond?
An Investment Bond is a tax-paid investment issued by a life insurance company. The structure can provide access to a selection of underlying investment options, with tax on investment earnings dealt with within the bond. The material you supplied notes a maximum tax rate within the bond of 30 per cent, although deductions and other features can result in a lower effective rate in some circumstances.
That can be attractive to some investors because there is generally no annual distribution of investment income for the bond owner to include in their personal tax return while the earnings remain within the structure.
Investment Bonds are also commonly associated with the 10-year rule. Broadly, where the relevant legislative requirements are satisfied, including holding periods and contribution rules, withdrawals after the applicable 10-year period can receive favourable personal tax treatment. Withdrawals of earnings during the earlier years can have different tax consequences. The precise outcome depends on the policy and circumstances, which is why the applicable Product Disclosure Statement and tax rules need to be considered.
Investment Bonds can therefore be useful in long-term planning, but they are not inherently education products.
So What Makes an Education Bond Different?
An Education Bond builds on many of those Investment Bond characteristics but adds a structure specifically designed to assist with education costs.
The material you supplied describes an Education Bond as having two components: capital and earnings. One of its important practical features is that capital can be accessed separately, while eligible education expenses can be funded through an education benefit from the earnings component.
This is where the specialist tax treatment becomes relevant.
Australian tax law specifically recognises benefits paid under qualifying scholarship plans to nominated education beneficiaries. The legislation provides rules for how those benefits are included in assessable income and the associated amounts used in calculating that treatment.
In the Education Bond structure described in your material, an eligible Education Benefit can also generate an additional Education Tax Benefit.
The example provided is particularly useful. If $10,000 is withdrawn from the earnings component for eligible education expenses, an Education Tax Benefit of $3,000 may be credited back to the bond owner's account. The net reduction in the bond's earnings component is therefore $7,000 rather than $10,000.
That education-specific benefit is the major distinction from an ordinary Investment Bond.
It Is Not Necessarily Just About School Fees
When people hear "Education Bond", they sometimes assume the money can only ever be used for a child's school tuition.
The structure described in your material is considerably broader. Eligible education claims can potentially relate to both Australian and international education expenses and can apply to adults as well as children, subject to the bond's rules and the particular expense meeting the relevant requirements.
That creates some interesting planning possibilities.
Consider grandparents who want to establish an investment for several grandchildren. Rather than establishing completely separate arrangements for every child, the Education Bond described in your material allows multiple education beneficiaries within a family bond, with beneficiaries able to be added after the bond has commenced without restarting its 10-year period.
That can be particularly useful because families change. Another grandchild might arrive. One child might attend university while another pursues a different path. Education costs themselves may also arise at very different times.
The ability to adapt can therefore matter just as much as the original tax strategy.
A Practical Example: Helping the Grandchildren
The example in the material made me think about conversations I have with grandparents.
Imagine a grandmother who has accumulated money she would ultimately like to use to help educate her grandchildren. She does not need the investment to provide her with regular income, but she does want the ability to access some capital if her own circumstances change.
She also wants certainty about where the remaining money goes when she dies.
An Education Bond can potentially address several of those objectives within the same structure. Education beneficiaries can be nominated, the owner may retain access to capital, and the bond may incorporate estate-planning features controlling who ultimately receives the proceeds.
Your supplied case study illustrates a grandmother named Helen who wants to leave $450,000 primarily to help fund three grandchildren's education while maintaining some access to the money herself. The structure permits education benefits during her lifetime and provides mechanisms for transferring the remaining bond balance to nominated beneficiaries.
That is a very different objective from simply asking,"Where can I invest $450,000?"
The real question becomes:"What do I want this money eventually to achieve?"
Where an Investment Bond May Be Different
If education is not the objective, the additional Education Bond features may be less relevant.
Someone may simply want a long-term tax-paid investment, an alternative way of structuring wealth outside superannuation, or particular estate-planning characteristics. In those circumstances, a conventional Investment Bond may be one of the structures considered.
If, however, a significant purpose of the investment is paying future education expenses, an Education Bond introduces a feature an ordinary Investment Bond does not have: the ability to claim qualifying education benefits under its education-specific framework.
The difference is therefore less about asking which bond is "better" and more about identifying what the money is intended to do.
Education Funding Can Be Part of Estate Planning Too
For our clients aged 50 and over, I think this is where the conversation becomes particularly interesting.
Education funding is often treated as something parents think about when their children start school. But it can also be part of intergenerational wealth and estate planning.
Some grandparents would rather see part of their wealth helping their family while they are alive. Paying for education can be one way of doing that. Others want to establish money today but ensure it ultimately benefits particular children or grandchildren after their death.
The Education Bond material also describes a Bond Guardian feature and "will-like" nominations intended to provide additional control over the transfer of the bond following death. The exact legal effect depends on the particular product terms, so this needs to be considered alongside the client's will and broader estate plan rather than assuming the bond replaces estate-planning advice.
This is important because investing, tax planning and estate planning should not operate in separate worlds. They ultimately need to support the same family objectives.
Start With the Purpose, Not the Product
Whenever I consider structures like these with clients, I prefer to begin somewhere other than tax.
What is the money actually for?
Is it specifically intended to educate children or grandchildren? Does the person providing the money want continued access to it? How many potential beneficiaries are there? When might the money be required? What happens if a child does not pursue the education originally envisaged? And what should happen to the investment if the owner dies?
Only once those questions are understood does it make sense to compare an Education Bond with alternatives such as an Investment Bond, investing personally, using an appropriate trust structure or, where relevant, making direct contributions towards education costs.
Tax can be important, but it should support the objective rather than create it.
For parents and grandparents who want to make education part of the legacy they leave their family, the distinction is therefore worth understanding.
An Investment Bond is principally an investment structure. An Education Bond combines an investment structure with additional provisions specifically designed around education funding.
Sometimes the most useful question is not"Which investment should I choose?"
It is "What do I want this money to make possible for my family?"
General information only
This article provides general information and does not take into account any person's objectives, financial situation or needs. It does not constitute personal financial, taxation or legal advice. Investment and Education Bonds have specific product terms, fees, investment risks, taxation rules, contribution requirements and eligibility conditions. Taxation outcomes can vary according to individual circumstances and legislative requirements. Before investing, the relevant Product Disclosure Statement and Target Market Determination should be considered, and appropriate financial, taxation and estate-planning advice obtained.
